Look around our society and you see signs of uninterupted progress. We have better technology for communication; cleaner lakes and rivers than a decade ago; more impressive pro athletes, and more channels on tv (although the verdict on quality of the content is still out).
From this perspective, CIS football stands out as a shocking exception. I recall football teams with large players with high skill levels. We could list the incredible athletes that we were able to watch but that would take up a lot of space.
Watch a game these days, like UWO versus Laurier or Ottawa and you see something that looks more like intramural flag football. Lot's of wobbly passes, lots of lob passes where 5 players have a chance to make a "500 up" style play. Remember the blocking and run plays of Western with Jamie Taras and Blake Marshall? Those were impressive to watch. The plays I saw last week on "The Score", not so impressive. The offense looks like they are calling "everyone go out for a pass".
Things aren't much better in the western conference. The Dinos look they are high school sized players and the passes are just as wobbly.
In my opinion, as the rest of the world has progressed, CIS football has regressed to a level of play not seen since the 1960s and 1970s. What happened?
A social scientist would observe that this regression has not been witnessed in other levels of football (with the exception of the CFL). In the US, the game showcases unbelievable athletes and play and if you watch hi-lites of stars from even 10 years ago, the improved skill level is impressive.
So what's wrong with the CIS? Can we identify something that adversely affected CIS football that did not affect other leagues and levels of play? One perennial contender for this factor is the decline of high school and junior league football in Canada. Fewer kids play, fewer quality coaches prepare the raw material. In contrast, US high schools continue to run their teams along a pro-model.
Another possibility is that the CIS really is a league of "student-athletes". The CIS, and most notably the OUAA, has rejected calls from the west to allow more use of scholarships to aid recruiting. Apparently we lose athletes to Div III college programs in the Dakotas over this issue. This issue has hit the point that UBC and SFU are planning to leave the CIS for the NCAA. Dan Federkeil who played for the Dinos is now an offensive lineman for Peyton Manning's Colts. He suggested that the intensity of work on the field is orders of magnitude higher in the US than in CIS. In other words, the pro game begins in the US at high school. In Canada, the career ends with the CIS level of play as its high point.
Finally, if you compare the rumored weight lifting records of players in the 80s and the lighter lifts of players today and it may be the case that CIS drug control policies have been legitimate whereas the NCAA and other levels in the US continue to develop their athletes with pharmaceutical help. In other words, the CIS shows us what we get in the game with clean athletes. A noble group of players but not as exciting a product.