
Oh dear. Some economists at the University of Calgary at upset that an Alberta economics council has no economists in it's roster.
AB economic council without economistsSays the author, Aidan Hollis:
"Twelve members, of whom one is an economist. Presumably the idea is that anyone is an expert in economics. Either that, or economists have not much to add."
Ahh, so they do have one economist on the panel. Sort of blows the whole point of the title with that little fact. So, let's look at the
roster.
Umm, Aidan? There are two people with PhDs in economics. Now, it might be fun to mock Aidan's ability to do arithmetic, but I will pass on that low hanging fruit and ask Aidan, "Is Dodge is the economist, or is Emerson?" And what discounts the other? More importantly, as economists are so eager to proffer their opinions in unrelated disciplines and discussions of policy, why is the author upset that others are doing the same thing? Yes, this is a gross generalization. But it reads better than "neener neener" and this is just a blog.
As for the number of Albertans on the panel, doesn't a free-market mind set look for the best and the brightest, and not just the closest? The University of Calgary and University of Alberta
might be home to the best and the brightest. But maybe there are smart people in the old world from whom you can learn. Or it could be that, much as Galbraith posited that the worst farmers headed west because they couldn't make a go of it in Ontario, the same could be true for academics out west.
I kid because I love.
As for academics, from Alberta, who are economists, how deep is that pool?
I'll leave the last word to Aidan.
"If you're so smart, why are you at a university in Alberta?"